Here is one of the best, and most responsibly critical, grapplings with Radical Orthodoxy that I have come across. Particularly disturbing is Reno’s insight into Milbank’s speculative tendencies, to the point that he reads the Gospels as “allegories of … metaphysics.” Also quite interesting: Reno’s hunch that Milbank’s speculative tendencies are rooted in his Anglo-Catholic convictions.

http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft0002/articles/reno.html